
Jury Clears Motor Grader Operator in Fatal US 17 Crash
A federal jury in Elizabeth City, North Carolina, found that Carl Douglas Swain, Jr., and R&D Excavating Co., Inc., were not negligent in a fatal June 2023 crash on US Highway 17. Joseph Angelo Scalco, IV, died when his work van struck the rear of a motor grader that Swain was driving at about 28 miles per hour in a 70-mile-per-hour zone. His estate claimed negligence, including negligence per se, and gross negligence. The defense cited the trooper’s finding that Scalco was inattentive. The Court granted judgment for the Defendants on gross negligence and punitive damages.








