Case Background
A Summerton, South Carolina, property owner sued the Town after police arrested him outside his own building in January 2023. John H. Newsome, III, claimed that officers detained and charged him without probable cause. The Town of Summerton denied wrongdoing and maintained that the arrest was lawful.
Newsome first filed suit in the Clarendon County Court of Common Pleas on January 2, 2024. He filed an Amended Complaint on January 6, 2025. On February 10, 2025, the Defendants removed the case to the U.S. District Court for the District of South Carolina. Judge Bruce Howe Hendricks presided.
Cause
According to the Amended Complaint, Plaintiff owned the former Piggly Wiggly property at 9 North Church Street in Summerton. He said he used the building mainly for personal storage. He also said he had never run a business there.
Plaintiff alleged that police, led by Chief Donnell Dixon, investigated him for operating a business without a license. He claimed a former chief had earlier entered with his consent and found no wrongdoing.
On January 25, 2023, Plaintiff went to the building with a contractor to remove items. According to the complaint, Dixon, Joseph Blanding, and Donnavan Pinckney arrived to force an inspection by the Fire Marshal. Plaintiff refused to consent to the entry. He alleged that officers then held him in the back of a police vehicle for over 40 minutes.
Plaintiff further alleged that Town Judge Percy Harvin declined Dixon’s request for a search warrant, finding no probable cause. Dixon then directed Sergeant Weldon Gregory to arrest Plaintiff for operating a business without a license.
Plaintiff alleged that Sergeant Gregory took him to the Town jail, where Blanding searched him. He said Blanding found his prescribed pain medication. Blanding then charged him with possessing a prescription drug without a prescription, despite Plaintiff’s explanation.
Injury
Plaintiff alleged that his mug shot was published to the general public. He said he had to hire an attorney to defend against the charges. A preliminary hearing on the prescription drug charge took place on February 28, 2023. A magistrate judge ultimately dismissed that charge, according to the complaint. Plaintiff alleged that the Town later agreed to dismiss the business license charge as well.
Plaintiff claimed that the arrest caused humiliation and lasting harm to his reputation. He also alleged anxiety, depression, sleeplessness, and emotional distress while the charges remained pending.
Damages
Plaintiff sought actual, compensatory, and punitive damages from the Defendants jointly and severally. He also requested attorney’s fees, costs, and interest. Against the Town, he sought injunctive relief to address what he called negligent training of its officers.
Key Arguments and Proceedings
Legal Representation
Plaintiff(s): John H. Newsome, III
Counsel for Plaintiff(s): Joseph Clay Hopkins | Dorie Lynn Sapp [Terminated: 10/31/2025] | Ray E. Chandler
Defendant(s): Town of Summerton | Mark Thompson [Terminated: 06/26/2026] | Donnell Dixon | Joseph Blanding | Weldon Gregory | Donnavan Pinckney
Counsel for Defendant(s): William Henry Davidson, II | John Pyatt Grimes, Jr. | Alexandra Evalyn Toney | Damon C. Wlodarczyk
Key Arguments or Remarks by Counsel
Claims
The Amended Complaint asserted seven causes of action. Against all Defendants, Plaintiff alleged defamation, false arrest, malicious prosecution, and civil conspiracy. Three more claims targeted the Town alone. These were negligent training, supervision, and retention; gross negligence; and a civil rights claim under 42 U.S.C. § 1983.
Plaintiff narrowed his case in a supplemental brief filed on October 18, 2026. He withdrew the defamation claim against all Defendants. He also agreed that the Town could not be liable under § 1983 merely for employing the officers. Instead, he relied on the Town’s failure to train and on Dixon’s own directions as a final policymaker.
Plaintiff cited Blanding’s incident report. According to the brief, Dixon ordered Plaintiff detained. Dixon later told Blanding to arrest him for interference if he refused to give his name and birth date. The brief stated that the report placed the discovery of the pills at the jail, after transport.
Plaintiff also cited Thompson’s deposition testimony that no business was operating at the property. He noted that the Town reported having no materials on its 2020 to 2023 training in probable cause and arrests.
Defense
The Town and the four officers filed a joint Amended Answer. They denied any campaign of harassment. However, they admitted that police investigated the building on or about January 25, 2023, because of complaints. They also admitted detaining Plaintiff for a time to ensure the safety of officers and the Fire Marshal.
These Defendants maintained that probable cause supported the arrest. They admitted both charges were dismissed but said the business license charge was not dismissed with prejudice.
In their supplemental brief, the Defendants argued that Plaintiff could not identify any unconstitutional Town policy. They noted that Plaintiff never brought § 1983 claims against the individual officers. They also stated that no expert witness had been identified to show deliberately deficient training. They planned to seek a directed verdict on the § 1983 claim.
The Town also claimed qualified immunity. It cited Plaintiff’s behavior, fumes from the building, the abandoned property, and the drugs found on him. The Defendants raised the intracorporate immunity doctrine against the conspiracy claim. Finally, they argued that the South Carolina Tort Claims Act made the officers improper parties to the state law claims.
In a declaration, Fire Marshal Mark Thompson said police called him to check for demolition without a permit. He entered the unoccupied building under the South Carolina Fire Code after Plaintiff refused to speak with him. He reported full fuel containers and a diesel generator that had run in a poorly ventilated space. He said he issued no citations and had no arrest powers. Plaintiff did not oppose Thompson’s motion for summary judgment. The Court granted it on June 25, 2026. That ruling disposed of the defamation, false arrest, malicious prosecution, and conspiracy claims against him. Judgment for Thompson followed on June 26, 2026, and the case proceeded against the remaining Defendants.
Jury Verdict
The case went to trial against the Town of Summerton alone, according to the verdict form and Judgment. The available documents do not explain how the other claims, including those against the four officers, were resolved. A jury of nine was seated on October 14, 2026, and trial ran from October 20 to October 22.
Plaintiff called Thompson by video deposition, along with Percy Harvin, Angel Pifer, Blanding, and Dixon. The witness list identified Harvin as a Clarendon County magistrate judge. The Town called Pinckney. The exhibits included a memo from Thompson, an incident report, and a Town ordinance.
On October 22, 2026, the jury returned a unanimous verdict for Plaintiff. It found that the Town’s officers lacked probable cause to arrest him on January 25, 2023. The jury also found that the Town negligently trained its officers and that this negligence caused Plaintiff’s injury.
Further, the jury found that the Town’s deliberately indifferent failure to train caused a violation of Plaintiff’s constitutional rights. It found that Plaintiff suffered an actual or compensable injury. The jury awarded him $100,000 in actual or compensatory damages. The verdict form contained no question on punitive damages. On October 23, 2026, the Court entered Judgment against the Town of Summerton for $100,000.
Post-trial Motions
On November 6, 2026, Plaintiff moved for an extension of time. The Court granted the motion on November 12, 2026. It extended Plaintiff’s deadline to file a motion for attorneys’ fees to November 20, 2026. The docket showed no fee motion as of that order.
Court Documents:
Documents are available for purchase upon request at [email protected]



