
Orthopedic Surgery Expert Witness Sues AAOS, Says He Was Punished for Testifying for Patients
A retired Army colonel and longtime expert witness says the orthopedic society punished him for testifying against fellow surgeons.
Expert insights, legal technology trends, and best practices for working with expert witnesses

A retired Army colonel and longtime expert witness says the orthopedic society punished him for testifying against fellow surgeons.

A California appeals court called an expert’s AI use “troubling” - including an AI-detector flag of “98 percent AI” - but deferred to the trial court’s finding that her opinion was her own, not ChatGPT’s

Five courts, from Virginia in 1989 to Arizona in 2025, admitted an economist's testimony over a challenge. The rulings cover a plaintiff with a thin work history, a defense economist in a death at sea, a child who had never worked, hedonic damages, and an economist who assumed an impairment rather than diagnosing it.

Four courts admitted psychiatric and psychological expert testimony over challenge between 2004 and 2026. The rulings cover a clinician qualified by experience, a defense psychiatrist who found no PTSD, an aggravation opinion built on a pre-existing disorder, and a psychologist who relied on self-report and testing. Here is what the courts accepted.

Five rulings show how courts handled epidemiology testimony on causation. Across two drug MDLs, a medical device case, a benzene claim, and an antidepressant case, courts admitted the experts' opinions over Daubert challenges. One court limited the scope of an opinion, and another called its ruling close. Here is what the courts accepted.

Between 2007 and 2026, courts in five states ruled on challenges to toxicology experts in cases involving a death in a fuel sump, creosote exposure, a workplace fall, a drugged-driving crash and a chemical plant fire. Each court allowed the testimony. This issue sets out what the courts accepted on qualifications, method and fit.

Between 2004 and 2023, courts in five states heard challenges to six accident reconstruction experts. The experts worked from tire marks, crush profiles, crash tests, simulation software and GPS records. Each court allowed the featured testimony. This issue sets out what the courts accepted on qualifications, method and fit, and what attorneys can take from the rulings.

An expert admitted at deposition that he used ChatGPT to research and draft his report. A Nevada federal judge then sorted his 40-page chat log by category: ChatGPT’s case summaries go to the other side, while his prompts, deposition prep, and draft work stay protected.

Five federal rulings show how lost profits testimony fared under challenge. Courts in Massachusetts, Delaware, West Virginia, and Louisiana admitted damages models built on party-supplied data, credited one in a $1,602,123 judgment, and cut one jury award where a rental price assumption had no evidence behind it.

Five rulings from courts in Missouri, Florida, Texas, and Louisiana show how life care planning testimony fared under challenge. Judges admitted a nurse's plan without physician review, credited a neurologist's cost estimate in bench findings, and upheld two jury awards for future medical expenses on appeal.