Case Background
Timothy Bohonowicz sued Pan Am Railways, Inc. and Springfield Terminal Railway Company, Inc. for negligence on November 19, 2019. He filed the case in the Massachusetts Superior Court for Middlesex County. According to the complaint, both railroad companies maintained principal places of business in Billerica, Massachusetts. The dispute arose from a drive in the dark across a rail crossing in Shelburne Falls in December 2016. Before trial, the Defendants stipulated that they had acted negligently. The jury then decided whether that negligence caused the Plaintiff’s injuries and what damages he should receive. Judge John P. Pappas presided over the trial in Lowell.
Cause
According to the complaint, a train the Defendants owned and operated derailed in Shelburne Falls early on December 18, 2016. At about 3:51 a.m., railroad employee Dan Nelson reported the derailment to the Massachusetts State Police. Nelson contacted the State Police again at about 5:44 a.m. He reported that the train had been cleared from the road crossings. He also reported that damaged track left vehicles unable to pass safely.
At about 6:40 a.m., Bohonowicz left his Buckland home and drove down Elm Street toward the crossing. It was dark. The complaint alleged that the crossing gates were not lowered and that no warnings were in place. It further alleged, on information and belief, that the gates had been lowered earlier and later lifted. Bohonowicz alleged that he crossed with due care and saw no irregularities. He alleged that he was violently jolted twice as his vehicle passed over the damaged track.
Injury
The complaint alleged that Bohonowicz suffered serious injuries when his car drove over the damaged track. Later pretrial filings described his claimed injury as a concussion. According to the Defendants’ motion in limine, the Plaintiff contended that the concussion resulted in permanent, disabling effects. Trial exhibits included medical records from Connecticut River Internists. Presentation slides titled “Diagnosis of Concussion or Mild TBI” were marked for identification.
Damages
The complaint sought compensation for pain and suffering, loss of income, and medical expenses. It also requested interest and costs. The complaint did not demand a specific dollar amount. At trial, the special verdict slip asked jurors to value three categories of loss. These were past earning capacity, future earning capacity, and past and future pain and suffering. The trial exhibits included a redacted summary table of lost earnings and benefits. Two tables valuing lost household services were marked for identification only.
Key Arguments and Proceedings
Legal Representation
Plaintiff(s): Timothy Bohonowicz
Counsel for Plaintiff(s): Thomas B. Lesser | Michael E. Aleo | Roger P. Lipton
Defendant(s): Pan Am Railways, Inc. | Springfield Terminal Railway Company, Inc.
Counsel for Defendant(s): Francis R. Powell | Melissa Nott Davis | Charles J. Swartwout | T. Mark Herlihy | Matthew E. Brown
Key Arguments or Remarks by Counsel
Claims
Bohonowicz asserted a single count of negligence against both companies. He alleged that the derailment resulted from the Defendants’ negligence. He claimed that they failed to prevent drivers from crossing the damaged track. He also claimed that they failed to warn approaching drivers about the hazard. The complaint further alleged, on information and belief, that employees had refused requests to lower the gates. According to the complaint, the Defendants’ negligence caused his pain and suffering, lost income, and medical expenses.
Defense
Springfield Terminal answered the complaint on January 21, 2020, and demanded a jury trial. It denied negligence and denied causing any injury to the Plaintiff. It admitted that a derailment of its train occurred at a crossing in Shelburne Falls. However, it specifically denied owning the track at issue. Springfield Terminal also raised several additional defenses. These included failure to state a claim, the Plaintiff’s own negligence, and persons or conditions outside its legal responsibility. It also asserted failure to mitigate damages and the statute of limitations. The docket shows that Pan Am Railways filed its own answer and jury claim the same day.
The defense position narrowed before trial. During trial, the parties filed a stipulation stating that the Defendants negligently failed to take appropriate precautions. The stipulation covered both preventing drivers from crossing the damaged track and warning them about it. The docket also reflects a defense motion to admit evidence of Social Security Disability Insurance payments. The Defendants separately moved to admit the Plaintiff’s statement to Travelers Insurance Company for personal injury protection benefits. The Defendants moved for a directed verdict at the close of the Plaintiff’s case. They renewed the motion at the close of the evidence. The Court denied both motions on the record.
Jury Verdict
The jury trial began on October 7, 2026, before Judge Pappas. Witnesses included the Plaintiff, his wife, Kara Bohonowicz, and his father, William Bohonowicz, Sr. The jury returned its verdict on October 21, 2026.
On the special verdict slip, jurors found that the Defendants’ negligence caused the Plaintiff’s injuries. They awarded $330,000 for past earning capacity. They awarded $300,000 for future earning capacity. They also awarded $200,000 for past and future pain and suffering. The total award came to $830,000. The foreperson certified that at least 10 of 11 jurors agreed on each answer.
The Court entered judgment on October 22, 2026. The judgment ran jointly and severally against both Defendants. It added $690,594.03 in prejudgment interest at an annual rate of 12 percent. Interest ran from the November 19, 2019, filing date across 2,529 days. The judgment total reached $1,520,594.03. By agreement of all parties, all trial exhibits went to defense attorney Powell at the end of trial. As of publication, the docket did not reflect any post-trial motions or notice of appeal.
Court Documents:
Documents are available for purchase upon request at [email protected]



